Evaluation Rubric
| |
Excellent 90-100%
|
Acceptable 70-89%
|
Unacceptable 69% or below
|
Individual Proposal Papers
30 points |
Paper includes a thesis statement which specifically states which artist they are recommending based on their expertise. Paper includes and introduction, a body and a conclusion. Topic sentences and transitions between paragraphs are included and are logical. Paper compares and contrasts their chosen artist to the other three artists using cited researched facts in a persuasive essay that supports their choice |
Paper includes a thesis statement stating which artist they are choosing. Paper compares and contrasts the artist to at least two of the other artists. Paper has an introduction, body and conclusion. Paper may be missing topic sentences and/or transitions. Paper includes cited researched facts but may not include enough of them to convince the reader of their choice. |
Paper does not include a clear thesis statement. There is no clear introduction, body or conclusion. Paper does not have topic sentences or transitions with in paragraphs. Paper compares and contrasts the artist to only one other artist. Paper does not include cited researched facts that support their choice. |
|
Paper includes a thesis statement which specifically states which artist they are recommending based on a collaboration of group discussion. Thesis statement includes a recommendation based on all areas of expertise. Paper is well organized with an introduction, body and conclusion. Topic sentences and transitions between paragraphs are included. Paper compares and contrasts all areas of their artist to all three of the other artist using cited researched facts from each of the group members. |
Paper includes a thesis statement which states which artist they are choosing. Paper has an introduction, body and conclusion. Paper may be missing topic sentences and/or transitions. Paper includes cited researched facts that compares and contrasts their chosen artist to at least two of the other artists. Paper includes a comparison and contrast in at least 3 of the areas |
Thesis statement is difficult to find. Organization lacks; it is difficult to find an introduction, body and conclusion. Paper compares and contrasts their chosen artist to only one other artist. Paper does not include cited researched facts. Paper does not include topic sentences or transitions in paragraphs. |
Group Presentation
30 Points |
|
Presentation includes an attention getter that serves as a thesis statement for their presentation. Presentation then includes a body and a conclusion. Group compares and contrasts their chosen artist to the other three in all areas of expertise. Presentation uses a multimedia visual aide that is creative and neat. The visual aide serves as a support for the presentation. Each group member participates in the presentation. |
Presentation includes a logical introduction, body and conclusion. Group compares and contrasts their chosen artist to at least two other artists in at least three of the areas o expertise. Presentation uses a multimedia aide that is creative and neat. The visual aide serves as a support of the presentation; however it may be distracting at times from the presentation’s message. Not all group members participate in the presentation. |
|
Presentation lacks organization; the introduction, body and conclusion are difficult to find. The group compares and contrasts their chosen artist to only one other artist in their presentation. The visual aide is sloppy, or does not support the goal of the presentation. Not all group members participate in the presentation. |